How do the accounts of a formerly incarcerated individual and a prison officer identify systemic and punitive barriers to rehabilitation in Pakistan, and what reforms could address these barriers?
Fatima Akber
https://doi.org/10.67698/pjpcr.2026.0214
Abstract
This paper examines how a former prisoner and prison officer depict systemic and punitive barriers to rehabilitation in Pakistan’s carceral system, and considers what policy interventions could address them. Pakistan’s criminal justice framework, shaped by colonial-era structures and later Islamization under the Hudood Ordinances, remains largely oriented around retribution rather than reform, while institutional constraints such as overcrowding, understaffing, and judicial backlog limit the delivery of rehabilitative services. Drawing on qualitative analysis of official legal documents, including the Pakistan Penal Code, the Prisons Act, and the Pakistan Prison Rules, alongside two written questionnaires from a formerly incarcerated person and a current prison officer, this study finds that rehabilitation exists in Pakistani law and policy; however, respondents describe inconsistent institutional implementation. Findings suggest a perceived gap between rehabilitation as a stated legal commitment and rehabilitation as a supported practice, particularly regarding post-release reintegration and the social consequences of a criminal record. The paper suggests the perceived gap may reflect weak mechanisms for applying rehabilitative policy rather than its absence; recidivism is not measured. It concludes with tentative policy recommendations addressing both punitive statute and systemic infrastructure, including reforms to disciplinary procedures, remission frameworks, post-release support systems, and vocational rehabilitation.
